American pies & tarts recipes with 400 or fewer calories costing less than $2.5 per serving

Sort: Popular Newest Rating
Show:
Ruby Red Strawberry Pie

Ruby Red Strawberry Pie

Couldn't be an easier pie to make - and perfect for summer's lighter menu fare. A nice do-ahead gelatin dessert that takes just minutes to prepare.…

Salad Foodie
Jun 2014
Professional
1 vote
4837 views
Old Fashioned Apple Pie

Old Fashioned Apple Pie

Truly an all time favorite; Tradition with a twist-you'll love it. Add some ice cream and its just perfect. Serve warm.

"Cheffie Cooks"
Sep 2016
Advanced
1 vote
1904 views
Apple Pie

Apple Pie

A friend gave us a bag of apples from their tree and so I decided to make a pie this afternoon. This is a great simple recipe and it tastes…

Aspen Lee-Moulden
Nov 2008
Intermediate
2 votes
4692 views
Mock Apple Pie

Mock Apple Pie

This pie tastes and looks amazingly like a real apple pie! I have made it several times for friends and family, and surprised them when I told them…

Florry
Nov 2012
Advanced
1 vote
2686 views
Sourcream Cheesecake Tart

Sourcream Cheesecake Tart

Catherine Pappas
Jul 2013
Intermediate
1 vote
1905 views
No-Bake Strawberry Pie

No-Bake Strawberry Pie

No-Bake Strawberry Pie is an easy and delicious cream pie recipe. The only cooking will be for the gelatin. Just assemble and refrigerate. It is…

RecipeKing
Dec 2014
Intermediate
1 vote
2846 views
Plum Sherry Tart

Plum Sherry Tart

The sherry and lemon zest give this plum tart a unique flavor. Be sure to use ripe, flavorful plums. You can use frozen plums but thaw them or heat…

Farrell May Podgorsek
May 2009
Advanced
1 vote
5060 views
Mini Peach Pies

Mini Peach Pies

They are so easy and if peaches are not your family’s favorite choose whatever your family likes best!

Carolinaheartstrings
Jul 2013
Intermediate
1 vote
5951 views
Layered Pumpkin Pudding Pie (easily converts to a lighter version)

Layered Pumpkin Pudding Pie (easily converts to a lighter version)

A change-of-pace pumpkin pie recipe for the holidays with the bonus - it…

Salad Foodie
Nov 2014
Professional
1 vote
4189 views
Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie

Jann from PA
Feb 2011
Intermediate
1 vote
1384 views
Orange~Lemon Cream (no bake) Pecan Pie

Orange~Lemon Cream (no bake) Pecan Pie

Citrus and Nuts can not get any better than that!

"Cheffie Cooks"
Apr 2016
Advanced
1 vote
4354 views
Pumpkin Chiffon Pie

Pumpkin Chiffon Pie

This was my late aunt's recipe. It is a wonderfully light alternative at the end of a large meal compared to the usual pumpkin pie. All who've had…

Margaret
Dec 2008
Advanced
1 vote
4903 views
No bake Reese's peanut butter pie

No bake Reese's peanut butter pie

This is a no-bake pie that is perfect to make any time of the year. It is a rich pie, so slice into smaller…

Deanna Martinez-Bey
Jun 2013
Advanced
1 vote
3616 views
Heart-Healthy Raspberry Pie

Heart-Healthy Raspberry Pie

Heart-Healthy Raspberry Pie-is a delicious recipe for a low calories, low fat, low cholesterol, low sodium, low carbohydrates, WeightWatchers…

RecipeKing
Jan 2015
Intermediate
1 vote
2550 views
Lemon Meringue Pie

Lemon Meringue Pie

This is one of my husbands favorite pies, he loves it extra tart and flavorful. After any dinner it is the perfect ending.

Ella Mangelos Velthoen
Feb 2015
Advanced
1 vote
2258 views