American pies & tarts recipes with 400 or fewer calories costing less than $2.5 per serving

Lighter Banana Cream Pie

Lighter Banana Cream Pie is a healthier version of the home style favorite dessert! Creamy and delicious, try this for dessert tonight!

Peanut Butter Pie

Lemon Curd

easy pecan pie

This is an easy recipe I like to make, and it also taste good!! This is one of the recipes that you make and everyone thinks you worked a long time…

Papaya and Pineapple Crumble

Twisted Butter’s Sweet Pie Crust

The holidays are a time to gather with family and share one thing we all truly love—homemade pies! Whether it…

Fresh Strawberry Pie- Best Ever

Fresh Strawberry Pie: This best-ever fresh strawberry pie is heaped high with fresh, juicy, ripe strawberries. Coat the berries with a perfectly…

Fudge Pie (quick, easy and NOT low cal!)

This is the most requested pie in our family and has been handed down for several generations. This is the…

Buttermilk Pie (will make 2 pies)

This came from a co-workers Great Grandmother

Fruit Pie

A graham cracker or vanilla wafer crust with bananas, pineapple, pecans, and maraschino cherries topped with whipped cream.

Sweet Potato Nutella Rolls

Okay, okay I admit it. I am a Nutella junkie. I have to be very careful and eat it sparingly, but I do, occasionally as a treat and I have to also…

Double Layer Pumpkin Pie

Cocoa Molasses Pie (filling)

I actually could not find a recipe for this and had to adapt my own so I would assume it is less common. This is, as odd as it sounds, a favorite of…

Custard Pie

Peanut Butter Apple Crisp Pie

A tasty Apple Crisp pie!