Hyped Up Shepherd's Pie with Mushrooms and Greens Recipe
I haven't a single fond childhood memory of shepherd's pie.
It's not that my mother made BAD shepherd's pie. Or even mediocre shepherd's pie. The truth is, my mother never made shepherd's pie... or cottage pie... or even cowboy pie. And I followed in her footsteps. Until sometime this fall.
I was inspired by the turnips at the farmer's market. They were gorgeous things -- all pretty and white, with the most perfect greens attached. I simply had to take them home with me, despite the fact that I had absolutely no idea what I'd do with them. Fortunately for me, it was the weekend. So, I had plenty of time to sit and wait for inspiration to hit.
Turns out it didn't take long. I ran across a post written by Peter from Kolofagas about Shepherd's Pie. He made that darned pie look so incredible, I could have just about eaten it right off the page. And right then and there, I knew what we were having for dinner.
At this point, you're probably starting to wonder what in the world this has to do with my turnips... but, trust me, they were part of my vision. When it came to the turnips themselves, it's possible I envisioned them roasting alongside a well-seasoned, pastured chicken. They'd caramelize in all that lovely schmaltz and become the best thing since mashed potatoes. But, the greens... why not create a shepherd's pie with some serious nutritional punch by throwing them into the mix?
And so, off to the kitchen we went. Chopped up plenty of vegetables -- onion, carrots, celery, garlic, and shiitake mushrooms. Oh, yes, and we can't forget about those gorgeous turnip greens.
I sauteed the shiitake mushrooms in a bit of butter. When they were done, I set them aside and gave the vegetables a bit of the same treatment. When theys were just starting to soften, I added about a pound of local ground lamb, browning that up nicely. I threw in a dash of worchestershire sauce, and I added a couple of teaspoons of fresh chopped rosemary and thyme leaves.
Once the herbs were incorporated and I could smell them letting off their fragrant oils, I added a bit of flour to make a roux. Stirred in about 1/2 cup of zinfandel, allowing the alcohol to dissipate, and then poured in about 1 1/2 cups of mushroom stock and tossed in a couple of bay leaves.
While the sauce was simmering, I whipped together my mashed potatoes and set them aside.
By then, the sauce had thickened up nicely and the flavors had really started to meld. I could tell simply by how everything smelled... but I took a quick taste just in case I needed to adjust the seasonings.
Determining that everything was just the way I wanted it, I added what a veg-head like myself would likely consider to be the Pièce de résistance -- those stunning turnip greens. I should mention that any tender greens would work well here -- swiss chard, mustard greens, or spinach would all do nicely. I left them in the stew just long enough for them to wilt (4-5 minutes, tops), stirred in the reserved mushrooms, and then I took everything off of the heat.
I poured it all into a large baking dish, spreading things out evenly.
And then I topped the whole mess with mashed potatoes. I did go through the effort of fluffing the potatoes up a little bit with a fork before sprinkling on a liberal dose of paprika... and that went a ways in making things look a bit more appetizing. But, I didn't go through quite the effort Peter did. He piped his potatoes on top of the pie so very beautifully, while I just slopped mine on, right out of the pan. Some of you may judge me for this. But, I can assure you, the finished product (while it might have been lacking in the looks department) tasted just fine.
In fact, once everything has baked together for about 45 minutes, and the kitchen starts filling up with the aroma of the lamb, the veggies, and the intoxicating scent of the rosemary and thyme, you'll forget all about the fact that your potatoes aren't all that pretty.
The torture comes when you take the casserole out of the oven. Despite the overwhelming impulse to scoop right in and start devouring your humble feast, it's really a much better idea to allow the casserole to rest for 15-20 minutes before serving. It will be painful, but I assure you, you'll be glad you waited.
After a good rest, you can scoop that delicious mess into bowls.
And yeah, you can even garnish your bowl with a nice sprig of fresh rosemary. It's a lovely touch -- but, like so many niceties, it's not necessary. In fact, the final product would be just as delicious eaten right out of the pan with a big fork. But, that doesn't make for a very good photo op. Does it?
The reality is, if you're looking for good old-fashioned comfort food, shepherd's pie is where it's at. If you're looking for a kicked up version with a bit of serious vegetable action -- this recipe does a pretty good job of delivering. And hey, if you decide to make it on one of those cold winter's nights... invite me over for a bite. It would be difficult to refuse.
Hyped Up Shepherd's Pie with Mushrooms and Greens
©BURP! Where Food Happens